HMU 495 Special Topics

Scoring for Media


Class Notes 01

Function of Music in Media


Submit Your Homework Here


What makes a good film score?

Compare these three horror-chase scenes and discuss how they serve the film and their impact on the audience. 

Halloween 1978   John Carpenter (Play to 4.05)
The Prowler 1981 Richard Einhorn
(Play to 5.13)
Scream 1996 Marco Beltrami (Play to 3.23)

  • Which do you feel was the most effective?
  • What could be done to improve each?
  • What are common traits?
  • Why are the traits common? What is their psychological effect?

Preliminaries


Please Read:


Text: OTT: The Film Making Team pgs 3-14


Text OTT: The Script Meetings, and Screenings pgs 15-20


Psychoacoustic Effects

  • Cognitive and Behavioral Effects of Music

    -a cognitive or behavioral effect of music elicits a change of state.  It can cause the listener to have increased or diminished awareness, cognition, and physical and emotional responses. 



    • The "Mozart Effect" - Cognitive effect

Listen to this and you will be smarter


In the spring of 1993 a psychologist named Francis Rauscher played 10 minutes of a Mozart Piano Sonata to 36 college students, and after the excerpt, gave the students a test of spatial reasoning. Rauscher also asked the students to take a spatial reasoning test after listening to 10 minutes of silence, and, after listening to 10 minutes of a person with a monotone speaking voice.

And Rauscher says, the results of this experiment seemed pretty clear. "What we found was that the students who had listened to the Mozart Sonata scored significantly higher on the spatial temporal task."




Productivity

In one study involving information technology specialists, she found that those who listened to music completed their tasks more quickly and came up with better ideas than those who didn’t, because the music improved their mood.Lesiuk, Teresa. " The Effect of Music Listening On Work Performance" Psychology of Music, http://pom.sagepub.com/content/33/2/173
      • Requires music that changes state of individual i.e. "Improved their mood"





See Homework
Cognition

In 2010, researchers at the University of Wales Institute showed that your ability to learn something new that is cognitively demanding decreases when you listen to music...regardless of musical preference.  This is particularly true of ones ability to recall the order of items within the presented list. Mental arithmetic. -Perham, Nick and Vizard, Joanne "Can preference for background music mediate the irrelevant sound effect?" Applied Cognitive Psychology  http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/acp.1731/full

  • Music must present Changing State Information
  • Task must involve seriation
  • The cognitive diminution is significantly greater  in music with Lyrics than instrumental Music





See Homework
Perception of Time
Perceived duration was longest for subjects exposed to positively valenced (major key) music, and shortest for negatively valenced (atonal) music.  -The influence of music on consumers' temporal perceptions: Does time fly when you're having fun?


See Homework
Athletic Performance

music has the potential to elicit a small but significant effect on performance (Karageorghis & Terry, 1997). Music also provides an ideal accompaniment for training. Scientific inquiry has revealed five key ways in which music can influence preparation and competitive performances: dissociation, arousal regulation, synchronization, acquisition of motor skills, and attainment of flow. Music in Sport and Exercise : An Update on Research and Application 

Noise as torture

Sound torture is a type of psychological warfare used to break the will of prisoners using loud music or white noise. While many of us use music to escape or even center ourselves, it can also be used as an instrument of torture under the right conditions. Torture Methods With Sound: How Pure Noise Can Be Used To Break You Psychologically

Frequency (pitch) as a determinant of dominance.  Whose your daddy now?

Bolinger, Ohala, Morton and others have established that vocal pitch height is perceived to be associated with social signals of dominance and submissiveness: higher vocal pitch is associated with submissiveness, whereas lower vocal pitch is associated with social dominance.  Influence of Pitch Height on the Perception of Submissiveness and Threat in Musical Passages


Homework 1


The first three aforementioned studies may suggest opposing conclusions.  Lesiuk suggests that there is a positive correlation between listening to music and completing a task and Perham and Vizard seem to suggest the opposite.  Milliman says it depends.   However, all studies require specific qualifications. 

1.  Discuss these qualifications and their implications in media (1/2 page)

2.  Give an example (URL) of music that supports your opinion of musics effect on Productivity, Cognition, and Perception of Time

3.  Is there a difference of importance and impact between cognitive and behavioral effects of music that is dependent on the type of media to which that music serves. If so, why?


IN CLASS

Discuss the aforementioned cognitive and behavioral effects of music and how they serve or detract from the give media. 


Titanic: My Heart Will Go On.  Celine Dion, James Horner, Will Jennings

Why are songs so frequently used in end credits? Music with Lyrics = cognitive diminution:
Interferes with understanding underlying story





Portal 2 Advance Video @ 10:20: Valve, Mike Morasky

Music somewhat devoid of "change of state" information does not detract from cognition necessary in Puzzel genre.


Gran Turismo 1: Game Play Various @ 2:35  Shade, Feeder
Rally Trophy 1: Trailer Andy Brick
@ 0.00





Homework #2


Quite a bit has been written about the psycho-acoustic effects of music.  Research the topic.  Find a journal article, study or relevant publication that presents a psycho-acoustic phenomenon.  Try to avoid topics specifically related to media.  Then, find a parallel example of that psycho-acoustic phenomenon demonstrated in music attached to 2 currently existing media sources  







The challenge to the composer of music for media is not only to understand the behavioral and cognitive effects of their music but, more importantly, to understand those effects and have the skill to write them, on demand, with purposeful intent. 

Writing a piece of music that could be used in an action sequence is simple but will hardly compete in its ability to serve the intent of the given media as a piece of action music composed with skillful intent.   Writing a piece of music designed to enhance a hairpin turn on a dirt track in a rally game will likely be very different than a piece of music designed to clarify the moment in battle the arch enemy becomes the sympathetic compatriot.

In order to write with purposeful (and hopefully skillful) intent, one must understand how the music serves the media.  Its not enough to just know the psychoacoustic effects of music.  We must be able to trigger those effects on demand.  In order to do so well, you must be able to answer this question:



Why is the music there?
  • Interpretative Anchors

    Interpretative Anchors help to clarify and enhance intent and combat emotional or cognitive ambiguity.  Most music that is intentional to media can be discussed in these contexts and it will serve us well to keep them in mind. 
    • Empathetic: Anticipatory or Parallel.   Mood matches or compliments action
    • Anempathetic: contradicting or indifferent to action
    • Emotional enhancement:  Increases depth of emotional experience
    • Anthropologically Significant:  Evokes a social/cultural precept
    • Representation of Epoch
    • Diagetic: Music whose source is visible on the screen or whose source is implied to be present by the action of the film
    • Behaivoral Provocation: Somewhat exclusive to interactive media (games) music can propel the audience into predictive behaivors



IN CLASS

Discuss the aforementioned interpretive anchors as they are applied to each of the following clips.






Jaws (1975): Video @ 1:06 John Williams

Empathetic Anticipation: Not just a nice day for a swim

In this early scene in the movie director Steven Spielberg slowly builds an uneasy anticipation.  Children splash in the water, young man searches uneasily for a little boy and, of course, the iconic oblivious childs song. However, it is not until the introduction of the Williams Jaws theme that we understand that anticipation as utter doom. 

Plot Summary

It's a hot summer on Amity Island, a small community whose main business is its beaches. When new Sheriff Martin Brody discovers the remains of a shark attack victim, his first inclination is to close the beaches to swimmers. This doesn't sit well with Mayor Larry Vaughn and several of the local businessmen. Brody backs down to his regret as that weekend a young boy is killed by the predator. The dead boy's mother puts out a bounty on the shark and Amity is soon swamped with amateur hunters and fisherman hoping to cash in on the reward. A local fisherman with much experience hunting sharks, Quint, offers to hunt down the creature for a hefty fee. Soon Quint, Brody and Matt Hooper from the Oceanographic Institute are at sea hunting the Great White shark. As Brody succinctly surmises after their first encounter with the creature, they're going to need a bigger boat.





Psycho 1960: Opening Credits Bernard Herman and the "Psycho Chord"

Emotional Enhancement.  Before we see the titles, we know what is this movie about.

Plot Summary

Phoenix officeworker Marion Crane is fed up with the way life has treated her. She has to meet her lover Sam in lunch breaks and they cannot get married because Sam has to give most of his money away in alimony. One Friday Marion is trusted to bank $40,000 by her employer. Seeing the opportunity to take the money and start a new life, Marion leaves town and heads towards Sam's California store. Tired after the long drive and caught in a storm, she gets off the main highway and pulls into The Bates Motel. The motel is managed by a quiet young man called Norman who seems to be dominated by his mother.




The Godfather 1972 : Luna Mezz 'O Mare Paolo Citorello Orig: Gioachino Rossini

Diegetic Music in the Godfather films helps to paint a convincing picture of Italian culture, particularly through Italian folk song and Italian opera thus also serving an Anthropolical function.

Plot Summary

When the aging head of a famous crime family decides to transfer his position to one of his subalterns, a series of unfortunate events start happening to the family, and a war begins between all the well-known families leading to insolence, deportation, murder and revenge, and ends with the favorable successor being finally chosen.






Dr. Strangelove 1964: Opening Title Sequence Try a Little Tenderness,  Harry M. Woods, Reginald Connelly, and Jimmy Campbell arr. Laurie Johnson

Anempathetic Contradiction

Plot Summary

U.S. Air Force General Jack Ripper goes completely and utterly mad, and sends his bomber wing to destroy the U.S.S.R. He suspects that the communists are conspiring to pollute the "precious bodily fluids" of the American people. The U.S. president meets with his advisors, where the Soviet ambassador tells him that if the U.S.S.R. is hit by nuclear weapons, it will trigger a "Doomsday Machine" which will destroy all plant and animal life on Earth. Peter Sellers portrays the three men who might avert this tragedy: British Group Captain Lionel Mandrake, the only person with access to the demented Gen. Ripper; U.S. President Merkin Muffley, whose best attempts to divert disaster depend on placating a drunken Soviet Premier and the former Nazi genius Dr. Strangelove, who concludes that "such a device would not be a practical deterrent for reasons which at this moment must be all too obvious". Will the bombers be stopped in time, or will General Jack Ripper succeed in destroying the world ?




Sim City 4: Wheels of Progress Andy Brick

Behaivoral Provocation

The quasi-minimalist nature of the score is derived from the direction to be "monotonous without being boring" in order to aid the player in long periods of repetitive actions.  Can this be a derivite approach to Milliman's (above) study on physical Behavior?  Does the repetitive nature of the music foster the repetitive nature of the gameplay?

Summary

The game allows players to create cities and regions of land.  Players can zone different areas of land as commercial, industrial, or residential development, as well as build and maintain public services, transport and utilities. For the success of a city, players must manage its finances, environment, and quality of life for its residents.

Braveheart:  Diagetic and Anthropological Anchors Simultaneously

Plot Summary

 William Wallace is a Scottish rebel who leads an uprising against the cruel English ruler Edward the Longshanks, who wishes to inherit the crown of Scotland for himself. When he was a young boy, William Wallace's father and brother, along with many others, lost their lives trying to free Scotland. Once he loses another of his loved ones, William Wallace begins his long quest to make Scotland free once and for all, along with the assistance of Robert the Bruce.


Anthropological  Anchor :  Pipes (Bagpipes, Highland Pipes etc)  are the most iconic of instruments native to scotland. 







Deliverance 1972 Dueling Banjos:  Arthur "Guitar Boogie" Smith.

Diagetic Music with Anthropological Anchor
City Vs. Country Of particular interest in this scene is the significance of "Im lost"

Plot Summary

The Cahulawassee River valley in Northern Georgia is one of the last natural pristine areas of the state, which will soon change with the imminent building of a dam on the river, which in turn will flood much of the surrounding land. As such, four Atlanta city slickers - alpha male Lewis Medlock, generally even-keeled Ed Gentry, slightly condescending Bobby Trippe, and wide-eyed Drew Ballinger - decide to take a multi-day canoe trip on the river, with only Lewis and Ed having experience in outdoor life. They know going in that the area is ethno-culturally homogeneous and isolated, but don't understand the full extent of such until they arrive and see what they believe is the result of generations of inbreeding. Their relatively peaceful trip takes a turn for the worse when half way through they encounter a couple of hillbilly moonshiners. That encounter not only makes the four battle their way out of the valley intact and alive, but threatens the relationships of the four as they do and are asked to do things they never thought possible within themselves.






Now Voyager:  Max Steiner

Emotional enhancement and clarification :   In the final climatic scene of Now Voyager, Charlottes need for Jerry is fully manifest.  His acceptance of her forbidden love is her only possible savior.  Jerry's uncommitted answer "shall we just have a cigarette on it" is clarified as an afirmation of his mutual love through Max Steiner's beautiful scoring. 

Plot Summary

 Forbidden Love story between
Charlotte Vale (Bette Davis) and Jerry (Paul Henreid)
Charlotte Vale suffers under the domination of her Boston matron mother until Dr. Jaquith gets her to visit his sanitarium where she is transformed from frump to elegant, independent lady. When she goes off on a South American cruise she falls in love with Jerry, already married. Back home she confronts her mother who dies of a heart attack. Charlotte, guilt-ridden, returns to the sanitarium where she finds Jerry's depressed daughter Tina. Tina achieves happiness through her attachment to Charlotte and the two move back to Boston. When Jerry sees how happy his daughter is, he leaves her with Charlotte.






BioShock Walkthrough Video @ 14:00 - End
If I didnt Care  The Ink Spots 1939

Representation of Epoch.  Although much of the score is in a typically thriller/horror genre, there is a significnat portion of music that  harkens to epoch of the game (1940-50-60) which itself has stylistic elements of that period.
BioShock is set in 1960 in the underwater city of Rapture, planned and constructed in the 1940s. The city's history is mostly revealed via audio recordings the player can collect during the game.






Homework #3


Find 3 media examples of any of the aforementioned musical Interpretive Anchors and present them in the next class.



Film Score Theory Analysis


Hollywood Cadences: Music and the Structure of Cinematic Expectation

An excellent analysis of different types of cadences that are emblematic in hollywood film scores.  If you are serious about scoring, this is a must read!  Big shout out to author and music theorist Frank Lehman

Additional scholarly analysis on film scores may be found via the Music Theory Online
smt

20th Century Fox Logo:  Note the very skilled balance of mixed modality and a traditional I-V-I
Brass and percussion for the Fanfare.  Strings and Winds for the lyrical statement.  Please see example 1 in the above article by
Frank Lehman for a much more indepth explanation of this iconic cue. 



This week's Film Score Theory Analysis Courtesy of FilmScoreAnalysis


"Shower Scene" - Psycho (Score Reduction & Analysis)